| Year | Best Forward | Best Back | Best and Fairest | Most Improved |
| 1927 | J.G. (Jim) Clark | J. (Jim) Larkin | J.G. (Jim) Clark | M. (Mick) Moloney |
| 1928 | J.G. (Jim) Clark | P. (Pat) Kelly | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1929 | Still Researching | Still Researching | Not Awarded | C. (Cyril) McCarthy |
| 1930 | J. (Jim) Portley, | P.A. (Phil) Clark, | Not Awarded | Still Researching |
| E. (Eric) O'Brien | C. (Cyril) McCarthy, | | L. (Les) Hammond |
| 1931 | E. (Eric) O'Brien, | C. (Cyril) McCarthy, | Still Researching | Still Researching |
| | V. (Viv) Mylne |
| | J. (Jack) Atherton |
| 1932 | No Annual Published | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching |
| 1933 | No Annual Published | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching |
| 1934 | No Annual Published | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching |
| 1935 | No Annual Published | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching |
| 1936 | R. (Richard) Bracewell, | T. (Tom) Roberts, | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| (Bernie) O'Sullivan, | E. (Evan) Thompson, | |
| | F. (Frank) Johnson, |
| | W. (William) Fraser, |
| | C. (Cyril) Wilkinson |
| 1937 | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching |
| 1938 | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching |
| 1939 | Still Researching | Not Awarded | G.K. (Kevin) Maccheroni | Not Awarded |
| 1940 | Still Researching | Not Awarded | J.E. (Jim) Purcell | Not Awarded |
| 1941 | Still Researching | N.V. (Neville) Downes, | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| | R.J. (Dick) Grant, |
| | G.F. (Gerry) Graham |
| 1942 | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching |
| 1943 | O. (Owen) Potter, | G.F. (Gerry) Graham, | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| E. (Eric) Corney, | F. (Fred) Schubert, |
| R. (Robert) Hoare | W. (Bill) Bayliss |
| 1944 | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching |
| 1945 | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching |
| 1946 | Still Researching | Still Researching | L.D. (Leo) Fallon | Not Awarded |
| 1947 | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching | Not Awarded |
| 1948 | Still Researching | Still Researching | M.J. (Mervyn) O'Malley | Not Awarded |
| 1949 | T.B. (Tom) Hurley | J.E. (John) Beiers | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1950 | P.D. (Paul) Coghlan | T.J. (Trevor) Manteit | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1951 | P.F. (Phil) Asmar | A. (Adrian) Hayes | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1952 | P.F. (Phil) Asmar, | M.P. (Paul) Sweeney, | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| J.G. (John) Ohlrich | A.S. (Adrian) Hayes |
| 1953 | C.J. (Cyrus) Weld | A.L. (Aldo) Erba | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1954 | J.E. (John) Nelson | W.B. (Walter) Wood | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1955 | J. (John) Barry | J.P. (James) Buckley | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1956 | J. (John) Barry | H.F. (Harry) Roberts | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1957 | K.J. (Kerry) Lusk | R.J. (Russell) Hawton | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1958 | R.E. (Richard) Peverill | E.J. (Errol) Maguire | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1959 | P.J. (Peter) Bliss | B.J. (Brian) Milburn | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1960 | A.J. (Anthony) Fanning | J.F. (John) Murphy, | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| | B.J. (Brian) Milburn |
| 1961 | K.M. (Kevin) Culla | L.R. (Lawrence) McIntosh | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1962 | D.R. (Denis) Sexton | G.R. (Gerard) McIntosh | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1963 | V.P. (Varro) Clarke | B.J. (Barry) Waters | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1964 | G.A. (Geoffrey) Daly | A. (Alex) Egoroff | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1965 | A.J. (Anthony) Andersen | A.P. (Allan) Edwards | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1966 | C.B. (Clive) O'Connor | R.M. (Ross) Anderson | P.J. (Peter) Maidens | Not Awarded |
| 1967 | G.M. (Gary) McMahon | M.J. (Michael) Burke | C.B. (Chris) Handy | Not Awarded |
| 1968 | J.G. (John) Gordon | G.A. (Graham) Vierow | C.B. (Chris) Handy | Not Awarded |
| 1969 | S.J. (Shane) Canniffe | G.A. (Graham) Vierow | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| 1970 | F.N. (Nick) Proctor, | Not Awarded | F.N. (Nick Proctor) | Not Awarded |
| P.M. (Philip) Corcoran |
| 1971 | A.A. (Tony) Anderson | P.G. (Pat) Creagh | P.J. (Peter) French | B.V. (Brian) Gardiner |
| 1972 | J.D. (John) Bliss | L.D. (Leo) McCourt | W.R. (William) Reid | Not Awarded |
| 1973 | M. (Mario) Vlasic | R.W. (Robert) Haimes | D.M. (Dave) Balwin | Not Awarded |
| 1974 | M.S. (Mark) Hickey | G.A. (Gerard) Gordon | J.B. (John) Webb | Not Awarded |
| 1975 | M.T. (Mark) Manteit | B.W. (Bruce) Humphrys | J.F. (John) Kerrisk | Not Awarded |
| 1976 | P.M. (Mark) Farmer | G.A. (Gerard) Gordon | J.C. (Jon) Windsor | Not Awarded |
| 1977 | M.I. (Mark) McBain | A.J. (Tony) Parker | M.A. (Mark) Moore | P.K. (Phil) Langley |
| 1978 | G.V. (Greg) Hampson | M.T. (Michael) Cook | M.G. (Michael) Maranta | B.J. (Bernie) Proberts |
| 1979 | D.J. (Damien) Frawley | M.T. (Michael) Cook | F.G. (Gerard) Forde | J.S. (Joseph) Vitelli |
| 1980 | S.A. (Scott) McNamee | G.W. (Geoffrey) Manteit | D.J. (Damien) Frawley | D.P. (Damian) Kelly |
| 1981 | J.A. (John) Matson | J.M. (James) Keim | M.P. (Michael) Lynagh | T.H. (Timothy) Dodson |
| 1982 | T.H. (Tim) Dodson | S.M. (Stephen) Partridge | D.M. (David) Porter | M.J. (Michael) Pollard |
| 1983 | P.A. (Peter) West | S.M (Stephen) Partridge | S.M. (Stephen) Partridge | B.T. (Brendan) Lumb |
| 1984 | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching | Still Researching |
| 1985 | J. (John) O'Keeffe | J.N. (John) Gibbons | P.J. (Patrick) Collins | M.J. (Matthew) Wright |
| 1986 | R.D. (Robert) Cullinan | A. (Andrew) Ryan | A.V. (Anthony) Vitanza | M.J. (Michael) Kissane |
| 1987 | M.A. (Michael) Ryan | S.D. (Simon) Courtice | A.W. (Andrew) Ryan | E.J. (Edmund) Nasser |
| 1988 | D.K. (Danny) Kissane | R.B. (Robbie) Martin | E.J. (Edmund) Nasser | S.J. (Simon) Nasser |
| 1989 | A.V. (Anthony) Samut | M.A. (Michael) Ford | S.J. (Simon) Nasser | V.G. (Vince) Corcoran |
| 1990 | T.F. (Tim) Fanning | R.M. (Russell) Klinge, | M.J. (Marcus) Fogarty | N.B. (Nicholas) Stiles |
| | L.A. (Luke) McElwaine |
| 1991 | N.B. (Nicholas) Stiles | L.L. (Leighton) Christopher | M.J. (Michael) Willcox | S.F. (Shawn) Tranter |
| 1992 | B.P. (Benjamin) Daly | A.S. (Anthony) Gibb | N.B. (Nicholas) Stiles | P.G. (Peter) McIntosh |
| 1993 | I.G. (Iain) Thomson | P.G. (Peter) McIntosh | I.G. (Iain) Thomson | M.K. (Malcolm) Blue |
| 1994 | M.D. (Mark) Ritchie | M.J. (Mark) Dunsdon | D.A. (Declan) Sherman | D.A. (Doogan) O'Hanlon |
| 1995 | D.R. (Damian) Prosser | S.J. (Stephen) Willcox | D.L. (Dominic) Townsend | T.J. (Timothy) McMeniman |
| 1996 | T.M. (Timothy) McMeniman | L.W. (Luke) D'Alterio | L.A. (Luke) Donald | B.C. (Brendan) Heim |
| 1997 | R.P. (Rudi) Vedelago | N.J. (Nicholas) McKeough | N.J. (Nicholas) McKeough | N.R. (Nicholas) Brusasco |
| 1998 | M.D. (Mark) Chisolm | D.J. (Damien) Hoo | S.J. (Simon) Reid | A.R. (Adam) Bettles |
| 1999 | H.N. (Heath) Mackintosh | N.R. (Nicholas) Forde | S.J. (Simon) Reid | P.C. (Patrick) Beckett |
| 2000 | G.F. (Graeme) Legh | M.J. (Michael) Buchanan | G.F. (Graeme) Legh | B.C. (Brendan) Scoble |
| 2001 | B.P. (Brendan) Jones | T.E. (Tom) Collins | C.C. (Charlie) Scott | B.C. (Ben) Forde |
| 2002 | J.M. (James) Kriukelis | B.C. (Benjamin) Forde | J.M. (James) Kriukelis | A. (Antonio) Lee |
| 2003 | E.P. (Edward) Bowden | E. (Enery) Maulio | J.W. (John) Toro | D.T. (Daniel) Kilmartin |
| 2004 | S.C. (Stephen) Cook | S.P. (Sean) Hennessy | B.J. (Ben) McCormack | T.M. (Tim) O'Shea |
| 2005 | T.E. (Tim) Buchanan | B.J. (Ben) Lucas | C.I. (Cameron) Jones | J.T. (Jack) Mullins |
| 2006 | P.L. (Patrick) Ritchie | J.T. (Jack) Mullins | P.J. (Phillip) Braban | K.L. (Kieran) McAuliffe |
| 2007 | C.J.M. (Charles) Freney | T.J. (Toby) White | S.J. (Sam) Gorey | N.J. (Nicholas) Ritchie |
| 2008 | L.B. (Liam) Gill | J.R. (James) Cornish | N.D. (Nicholas) Buchanan | M.J. (Matt) Lucas |